Why is duplicate publication a problem?

Table of Contents

Duplicate publication of original research is particularly problematic because it can result in inadvertent double-counting of data or inappropriate weighting of the results of a single study, which distorts the available evidence.

What should you do if you suspect redundant duplicate publication?

What to do if you suspect redundant (duplicate) publication in a published manuscript.

The instructions to authors should state the journal’s policy on redundant publication.
Asking authors to sign a statement or tick a box may be helpful in subsequent investigations.

Why you should not submit your work to more than one journal at a time?

There are two reasons why editors forbid multiple submissions. The main one is because submitting a manuscript to more than one journal at the same time is a waste of reviewers’ time, and that time is precious to editors. The result would be that the major journals would be swamped with submissions.

Which of the following is considered duplicate submission of previously published content?

It has also been termed multiple submissions or dual submission. While duplicate publication involves the submission of a previously published manuscript to another journal, simultaneous submission involves the submission of a manuscript that is under consideration at another journal.

What is double submission?

Double submission can be defined as “the submission of a paper to a journal after that is under concurrent review by another publication”. Double submission is also considered unethical because it may result in double publication.

Can you present the same paper at different conferences?

It is fine to present the same research at more than one conference. It is important to know that different audiences will give you different kinds of feedback. Certainly you should reframe each paper to match the focus of the particular conference. Likewise, change the title to reflect this specific reframing.

What is a reprint submission?

A reprint submission may be the way to go. If the term reprint is unfamiliar to you, it’s simply a story you’ve already published. (It’s also a story where certain rights have reverted back to you. When you send that story to another market who accepts previously published works, it’s a reprint submission.

Can I submit to more than one publisher?

It’s perfectly acceptable to send a query simultaneously to multiple publishers. If more than one press responds with interest, the author should study the presses and rank them. The full book proposal should be sent only to one press. If it passes on the project, then the proposal may be sent to another.

What is duplicate submission?

Duplicate submission / publication: This refers to the practice of submitting the same study to two journals or publishing more or less the same study in two journals. These submissions/publications can be nearly simultaneous or years later. “Self-plagiarism” is considered a form of redundant publication.

What is considered previously published writing?

The definition of previously published: If your poems, stories, or essays appeared in a book, journal, anthology, textbook, newsletter, newspaper, magazine, or any other publication, your work was considered published. If it didn’t, it wasn’t.

What is salami slicing in research?

In essence, salami slicing refers to splitting of data derived from a single research idea into multiple smaller “publishable” units or “slices.”[1] This practice is neither new nor entirely culpable.

Is a government document a secondary source?

Also available online. Note: All of these encyclopedias are secondary sources, but they may lead you to primary sources such as Acts of Congress and other laws, federal regulations, court cases and other government documents (congressional hearings, etc.)

What are secondary legal sources?

Secondary sources of law are background resources. They explain, interpret and analyze. They include encyclopedias, law reviews, treatises, restatements. Secondary sources are a good way to start research and often have citations to primary sources.

What is the difference between a primary source and a secondary source in history?

Primary sources can be described as those sources that are closest to the origin of the information. Secondary sources often use generalizations, analysis, interpretation, and synthesis of primary sources. Examples of secondary sources include textbooks, articles, and reference books.

Can authors publish the same content in multiple papers?

In allowing publication of a manuscript, the author must assign copyright to the journal’s publisher, and obviously it is illegal to assign copyright of the same material to multiple journals and publishers.

What is a secondary publication?

Secondary publications are summaries and syntheses of primary publications. Examples of secondary publications include practice guidelines, review articles, and meta-analyses. Tertiary publications are printed textbooks and online hypertexts.

Is Textbook a secondary source?

A textbook can either be a secondary or tertiary source and, in seldom cases, a primary source. In most cases, the author of a textbook interprets prescribed theories of a topic and would, therefore, be a secondary source. A textbook can be a tertiary source when it simply indexes information about a particular topic.

Can the same article be published twice?

If an author publishes the same article twice, he or she is guilty not only of the misconduct of duplicate publication, but also of plagiarism; this time, the author has plagiarized himself or herself. Unfortunately, such blatant misconduct is not rare.

Is a history book a primary or secondary source?

Examples include journal articles, reviews, and academic books. A secondary source describes, interprets, or synthesizes primary sources….What is a primary source?

Research field	Primary source
History	Letters and diaries Photographs and video footage Official documents and records Physical objects